SaintPaulTrash.com

Affiliated with:    StPaulTrash.com

Contact Us: info@saintpaultrash.com 

651-300-7808
(voicemail or text)

Facebook: St Paul Trash Lawsuit
Sign Up: Email newsletters 

  

Home Page StPaulTrash.com
Affiliated Website
STATUS
LAWSUIT-1:  Unlawful Denial of
Referendum on ORD 18-39.
Documents to Download
Various Information
Problems?
What are some of the problems that have been identified?
Questions?
FAQ Page 
   Civil Penalties   
  City of St. Paul seeks broad new authority to impose civil penalties for each violation of a city ordinance.  
Trash Cart Mandate
How many carts?
At what cost?
Can I share or opt out?
Community News
Trash-related resources.  Community input & feedback.  Miscellaneous links. 
Real-Life Examples
Financial & Space Implications
Send Comments
to City Council.  Links to the most-recent version of Ordinance language.

   

DOCUMENTS to DOWNLOAD

(Click images or highlighted text to download .pdf files)

saintpaultrash.com/downloads.htm

     On June 20, 2018, the MN Supreme Court recognized that citizens still have rights.  Halper & Joseph founding partner, Greg Joseph, represented residents of Bloomington, MN to a Minnesota Supreme Court decision (the Jennissen case) that reinforces the right of residents to determine their own trash haulers over mandated use of a hauler selected by city officials.

     On November 14, 2018, the St. Paul City Council, via Resolution #18-1922 that disregards binding precedent directly on point, voted 6-1, denying citizens' right to submit trash Ordinance #18-39 to a ballot vote.  Despite finding our Petition “legally sufficient,” the City claims that the subject matter is “not appropriate to submit to the electorate.”

     We (residents of St. Paul, MN) strongly disagree, and in order to enforce our right to vote on St. Paul's new trash plan, our only remedy is to sue the City.  We have retained Greg Joseph, the same attorney who successfully defeated the pre-emption claim on behalf of residents in Bloomington, MN.

Lawsuit Filed in District Court:
February 07, 2019
Case No. 62-CV-19-857
110-Pgs / 22MB (large file)

Petition for Correction of Ballot Error
 and for Declaratory Judgment

   

Attorney's letter to
the City of St. Paul:

January 09, 2019

Unlawful Denial of Referendum
on Ordinance 18-39

City Council
Resolution 18-1922:
November 14, 2018

Petition is Legally Sufficient
but Subject Matter is Not Appropriate
to Submit to the Electorate

MN Supreme Court precedent:
   June 20, 2018

Jennissen vs. City of Bloomington

 
 

Unpaid / Delinquent Trash Bills

February 2019 -- for October to December 2018   (there are 8,452)

 

saintpaultrash.com/downloads.htm

 

Breakdown by ZIP Code 

 
  • Sherburne Ave;  80 properties;  $9,578.83 Total unpaid

  • Hague Ave;  56 properties;  $6,393.30 Total unpaid

    

Assessment Rolls  [per City Council resolutions]
[Name, Address, Delinquency, etc.    Public record .pdf files as provided by City of St. Paul]

Approving the City’s cost of providing Collection of Delinquent Garbage Bills for service during October to December 2018, and setting dates of Legislative Hearings and City Council public hearing for May 22, 2019 to consider and levy the assessments against individual properties.

Legislative Hearings:    April 11, 2019   [for disputes]

     09:00    (Res 19-497 -- 07:53:47  3/15/19 -- 302 -- $36,357.74)

     10:30    (Res 19-498 -- 07:56:28  3/15/19 -- 282 -- $29,404.40)

     13:00    (Res 19-499 -- 07:58:26  3/15/19 -- 302 -- $31,256.22)

     14:30    (Res 19-500 -- 08:01:09  3/15/19 -- 289 -- $30,042.48)

Legislative Hearings:    April 18, 2019   [for disputes]

     09:00    (Res 19-503 -- 08:33:21  3/15/19 -- 334 -- $35,525.79)

     10:30    (Res 19-504 -- 08:51:19  3/15/19 -- 319 -- $33,859.10)

     13:00    (Res 19-505 -- 09:00:03  3/15/19 -- 304 -- $32,672.11)

     14:30    (Res 19-506 -- 09:02:41  3/15/19 -- 304 -- $31,399.69)

  • RES 19-513, 19-514  
      
    0.6 MB; 207 Pages    [4/25 = Short day for hearings?]
        Adoption:  04/03/2019       [partial list]
        $66,497.53 Unpaid;  618 Properties

Legislative Hearings:    April 25, 2019   [for disputes]
     09:00    (Res 19-513 -- 10:41:56  3/20/19 -- 293 -- $28,439.33)

     10:30    (Res 19-514 -- 10:48:07  3/20/19 -- 325 -- $38,058.20)

     13:00    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)

     14:30    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)

  • More to come...   ~ 04/10/2019 (?)
       
    Adoption:  04/10/2019 (?)

Legislative Hearings:    ~ May 02, 2019   [for disputes]
     09:00    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)
     10:30    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)

     13:00    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)

     14:30    (Res 19-5xx -- __:__:__  x/xx/19 -- xxx -- $___)

  • More to come...   ~ 04/17/2019
Legislative Hearings:    ~ May 09, 2019   [for disputes]
  • More to come...   ~ 04/24/2019

Legislative Hearings:    ~ May 16, 2019   [for disputes]
  • COMBINED FILE for easier searches (large file, 3.1MB, includes all above assessment rolls)
           $327,015.06 Unpaid          3,054 Properties         Note: This is about 1/2 of 4th Qtr 2018.
           More later ... ... ... whenever the City releases lists for/at future Council meetings.
  • Public Hearing @ City Council:    May 22, 2019  (before ratification of final assessment #'s)
    All this for just 3-months of unpaid bills:    October-November-December 2018
    Deadline to appeal unfavorable outcome @ District Court:   JUNE__, 2019  [more info below]
   

https://eproperty.logis.org/stpaul/assessments/search

On 08/08/2018

ORDINANCE 18-38
amended

Chapter 60
St. Paul Administrative Code

     Are you being billed for empty, unnecessary, unused &/or unaffordable trash carts?

     If you did not pay, the city will pay your hauler and demand payment from you.  If you fail to appeal the city's order, the city will levy hefty fees and assess your property tax, you will be forever barred from making any future appeals and the assessment (whether proper or improper) shall be final.

You (we!) can fight back...

     APPEAL: " Within twenty (20) days after adoption of the resolution adopting the property services costs, any person aggrieved may appeal to the district court."

saintpaultrash.com/downloads.htm

City of St. Paul -- Trash Cart Mandate

Annual costs + Other information

How many carts are required for my building?

Can I share a cart with my neighbor(s)?

As a "zero waster," can I opt out?

   

 

C

O

D

E

Chapter 220, St. Paul Legislative Code  (Adopted 09/05/2018, Ordinance 18-39)

    Residential Coordinated Collection

This ordinance is the subject of a Petition for Referendum, and it is also the subject of a lawsuit in Ramsey County District Court.  If plaintiffs' claims prevail, operation of ORD 18-39 (i.e., Chapter 220) will be suspended pending a referendum in November 2019, at which time a majority of voters might choose to repeal ORD 18-39.

 

220.07 e.  Assessment of delinquent Accounts.   The delinquent account shall be a debt owed to the city and any unpaid costs shall be collected by special assessment under the authority of Minn. Stat. § 443.29 and the Saint Paul City Charter by the procedure outlined in Chapter 60 of the Saint Paul Administrative Code.  Unpaid costs shall not include additional interest beyond that charged in section (a) above.  Action under this section does not preclude any other civil or criminal enforcement procedure. 

 
   
A

U

T

H

O

R

I

T

Y

MN Statutes, Chapter 443

    Rubbish Removal 

 
§ 443.29  RATES CHARGED AGAINST PREMISES.  The rates for rubbish disposal shall be a charge against the premises from which rubbish is collected, and the owner, lessee, or occupant of the premises, or against any or all of them, and any claim for unpaid rates charged or rentals which have been properly billed to the occupant of the premises may be collected in a civil action in any court of competent jurisdiction, or, in the discretion of the city council of the city, may be certified to the county auditor with the taxes against such property served, and shall be collected as other taxes are collected.  Payment of delinquent rentals shall be credited to the fund as are current funds for that purpose.  
§ 443.27  DEFINITIONS  
  For the purpose of sections 443.26 to 443.35, the word "rubbish" is defined as any one or all of the following substances: offal, garbage, ashes, barnyard litter, manure, rubbish, barnyard cleanings, dead animals, or any other foul or unhealthy stuff or material. For the purposes of such sections all of said substances are hereinafter referred to as "rubbish".
The words "rubbish disposal" mean the removal, collection, and disposal of "rubbish" from public or private property within any such city.
 
§ 443.28  POWERS OF COUNCIL.   
The council of any such city is authorized to employ present facilities, and to provide additional facilities, for rubbish disposal.
Rates for such rubbish disposal, together with regulations incident thereto, shall be established by ordinance.

Such rates shall be as nearly as possible just and reasonable, taking into account 

-- the character, kind, and quality

of service,

of rubbish and method of disposition,

-- the number of people served at each place of collection, and

-- all other factors that enter into cost of service, including interest on principal, investments, amortization of principal, depreciation, and other overhead charges upon facilities now owned and operated by any such city, or hereafter acquired for such use.

Said rates when fixed may be billed in such manner as the city council may determine, or added to and collected with water bills and bills for sewage disposal rendered to owners, lessees or occupants of property, or as herein otherwise provided.
 
  

P

R

O

C

E

D

U

R

E

Chapter 60, St. Paul Administrative Code  
60.03 f.  Certification to county for collection with taxes.  After adoption by resolution of the property services costs and assessment rates therefore, the city clerk shall transmit a certified copy of said resolution to the county department of property taxation to be extended on the proper tax list of the county and collected the following year along with current tax   
60.03 g.  Appeal.  Within twenty (20) days after adoption of the resolution adopting the property services costs, any person aggrieved may appeal to the district court in the manner set forth in Chapter 14 of the City Charter.  
       
Chapter 14, St. Paul City Charter  
Sec. 14.01. - Power to levy assessments.  

The city shall have the power to levy assessments to pay all or any part of the cost of improvements as are of a local character, but in no case shall the amounts assessed exceed the benefits to the property.

 
Sec. 14.01.2. - Charge for services.  

The council may provide, by ordinance, that the cost of any services such as street cleaning, street flushing or oiling, and tree trimming on streets, sidewalks, boulevards, or other public or private property undertaken by the city may be charged against the property benefited.  Service charges shall be collected and levied like special assessments or in such other manner as the council determines.  The council shall have the power to abate nuisances on any particular property and shall have the power to collect the costs of such abatement as a special assessment in the manner provided in this chapter.

 
City Charter Sec. 14.01.4. - Appeal.  

(1)  Within twenty (20) days after the order adopting the assessment, or making a reassessment, a new assessment or supplemental assessment, any person may appeal to the district court by filing a notice of appeal with the city clerk stating the grounds upon which the appeal is taken.  Such notice shall be filed with the clerk of the district court within ten (10) days after the filing with the city clerk.

 

(2)  The only defense to an assessment shall be that the assessment is fraudulent, or that it is made upon a demonstrable mistake of fact or law, or that the assessment is in an amount in excess of the actual benefits to the property.  The jurisdiction of the court shall not be affected by an error, act or omission not affecting the substantial rights of any person.

 

(3A person who fails to file the notice of appeal with the city clerk within the time specified or fails to file the notice of appeal with the district court within the time specified shall be forever barred from proceeding with an appeal and trial in said court, and the assessment shall be final.

 

(4)  In case of an appeal, the appellant shall be given a copy of the assessment roll or any part thereof upon payment of an amount designated by administrative ordinance.  This copy shall be certified to by the proper city officers and filed by the appellant in the district court.

 
 
Cost Analysis by John Genereux - August 2018

saintpaultrash.com/downloads.htm

St. Paul

"Free Market"

Maplewood

"Organized" Prices

St. Paul

"Organized" Prices

  

Civil Penalties

OCT 2018:  City-mandated payments for "service" of unnecessary empty trash carts.  City says non-payment is violation.
OCT-NOV-DEC 2018:
  6,600+ delinquent garbage accounts as of 4/1/2019 (City will pay $630,000+ to haulers).
APR-MAY 2019:  City initiates ratification of property tax assessments for unpaid garbage bills for "services."
APR 2019:  City seeks broad new authority to impose civil penalties for each violation of a city ordinance.

A PETITION REQUESTING A REFERENDUM IS CIRCULATING

Ordinance 19-18 amends the City Charter so that “the Council shall have full power and authority to establish, enforce, alter, amend or repeal a procedure by ordinance to impose civil penalties for each violation of a city ordinance.

We, being registered voters residing in the City of Saint Paul, Minnesota, request a referendum on Ordinance 19-18 per MN Statutes 410.12, Subd.7.

Download:  Petition, Instructions, Notice of Public Hearing

  

Print as LANDSCAPE, Double-sided

A referendum is the process by which a legislative ordinance adopted by the City Council is then "referred" or submitted to a vote to be taken by the city's residents, allowing the people to either approve or reject that ordinance. 

  • Petitions signed by voters may be delivered to the City after this ordinance is adopted, but will not be accepted more than 60 days after adoption & publication. 

  • We hope you will help by printing the petition and gathering signatures.

  • FAQ:  The City of St. Paul continues to ignore our right to a referendum on the new trash program.  Will they reject this petition also?

    • A:  We think not.  State law is clear about citizens' right to petition on this subject matter.  [But......]

  • FAQ:  How many signatures are required?

    • A:  State law requires at least 2,000 signatures of registered St. Paul voters.  We aim to collect at least 2,500 because some will be rejected.

  • FAQ:  Is a petition the only way to require that this ordinance be submitted to voters?

    • A:  No.  Because this is a charter amendment, the ordinance is enacted only if it receives an affirmative vote of all members of the city council and is approved by the mayor.  If the council vote is not unanimous, the council may submit the ordinance to the people and it will become effective only when approved by the voters.  [In St. Paul, charter amendments seem to be a "bigger deal" than garbage ordinances that demand payment for unnecessary & undelivered services.]

  • THANK YOU!